Media18 November 2026

One released hostage, Yocheved Lifshitz, spoke at a press conference about care she received with a small group, while also recounting that her abductors beat her.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld adalah nama pena dari meja redaksi Fakta & Mitos Hasbara. Artikel di meja redaksi ini ditulis dan dipublikasikan secara otomatis oleh kecerdasan buatan, tanpa ada yang memeriksanya sebelum publikasi.

Mitos

Released Israeli hostages held a press conference confirming Hamas treated them like honored guests and never abused them.

Fakta

One released hostage, Yocheved Lifshitz, spoke at a press conference about care she received with a small group, while also recounting that her abductors beat her. Other survivor accounts and medical records document serious abuse and deprivation in Hamas captivity.

The claim that Israeli hostages collectively appeared at a press conference to certify Hamas’s kindness is a distortion of one survivor’s account. On October 24, 2023, 85-year-old Yocheved Lifshitz spoke to reporters in Tel Aviv after Hamas released her from 17 days of captivity. She described receiving food and medical attention in the room where she was held with several other captives. She also recounted being beaten during her abduction, and her daughter stressed that Lifshitz could not speak for hostages held elsewhere.

What Lifshitz actually said

The Times of Israel’s report from the press conference records both parts of her account. Lifshitz said a medic and doctor visited, that captives received medicine and a mattress, and that guards cleaned the toilets. She described one daily meal of pita, cheese and cucumber, and said the captives ate what their guards ate. Asked about her captors, she called them friendly and said they took care of her group’s needs.

Those remarks were real, and they deserve accurate reporting. So does the rest of the testimony. Lifshitz said men beat her with sticks while transporting her on a motorcycle from Kibbutz Nir Oz into Gaza. She said the blows made it difficult to breathe. She described the October 7 attack on her kibbutz as a “hell” and said terrorists rampaged through it. Her positive description of care during part of captivity did not erase the violent kidnapping that preceded it.

The press conference was Lifshitz’s account, not a statement issued by a group of released hostages. Her daughter Sharone Luton said she was glad her mother had been treated well, but added that her mother did not know how other captives were being treated because she had seen only about 25 people. Her husband Oded remained captive. Turning this narrow testimony into a universal claim assigns Lifshitz knowledge she explicitly did not claim to have.

Captivity varied, and abuse is documented

Survivors’ experiences were not identical. A favorable description of a medic’s conduct toward one group cannot establish conditions for hostages held in other places, by other guards or at different times. It also cannot turn hostage-taking itself into hospitality: captives were held against their will, separated from families and denied independent access to the outside world.

In a later Times of Israel report on Amit Soussana, the released hostage described being chained in a dark room and sexually assaulted by a guard. The newspaper reported that her account matched information she had given medical professionals and a social worker soon after release. Her testimony is one individual account, like Lifshitz’s, but it directly refutes the sweeping assertion that captors never abused hostages.

Medical records and interviews also informed an Israeli Ministry of Health report on 12 hostages released in January and February 2025. The report says survivors described beatings during abduction, prolonged confinement in cramped underground spaces, insufficient food and water, untreated injuries, threats and medical neglect. It identifies the scope of its review: those 12 returnees. Its findings do not claim every hostage had the same experience; they document grave conditions among those examined.

Amnesty International’s investigation likewise distinguishes Hamas’s public claim of humane treatment from the evidence it reviewed. Amnesty records that Hamas spokesmen called captives guests or said they were treated humanely. The organization also documents testimony and other evidence of physical, sexual and psychological abuse, and concludes that Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad subjected hostages and their families to psychological abuse. The group’s own reassuring language is a claim about its conduct; it does not prove the claim true.

A staged release is not proof of humane captivity

Hamas also controlled the circumstances in which some captives appeared before cameras. A hostage’s gesture, a thank-you note, or a brief statement during a release cannot by itself show that the person was free to speak or describe every part of captivity. Lifshitz’s comments came after her release, in a public press conference, and should not be conflated with remarks made while hostages remained under armed guard. Neither type of appearance justifies generalizing from one person to all others.

The sound conclusion is specific: Lifshitz said that she and several others received food, hygiene and medical care from some captors during part of their captivity. She also reported a beating during abduction. Her daughter said she did not know how other hostages were treated. Subsequent first-person testimony and medical reviews documented severe abuse and deprivation among other captives. That record makes the claim of universal, abuse-free treatment false; it does not require denying Lifshitz’s account of care.

Sumber

  1. 1
    Freed Hamas hostage recounts ordeal, slams Israeli failures, speaks well of captorshttps://www.timesofisrael.com/freed-hamas-hostage-recounts-ordeal-slams-israeli-failures-speaks-well-of-captors/amp/Tepercaya
  2. 2
    Released hostage Amit Soussana recounts sexual assault at hands of Hamas captorhttps://www.timesofisrael.com/released-hostage-amit-soussana-reveals-she-was-sexually-assaulted-by-hamas-captor/Tepercaya
  3. 3
    Impact of Captivity on Hostages Who Returned from Gaza During January–February 2025https://www.gov.il/BlobFolder/news/delegation-of-mothers-of-hostages-meets-with-the-president-of-the-red-cross-in-geneva-12-aug-2025/en/English_Swords_of_Iron_DOCUMENTS_Impact-of-Captivity-Report-FULL-250812_105125.pdfTepercaya
  4. 4

Pengaturan aksesibilitas

Pengaturan ini disimpan di perangkat ini.

Pratinjau

Baca dengan nyaman, sesuai keinginan Anda

Sesuaikan halaman ini saat Anda membaca. Jelajahi materi

Teks
Ukuran teksBerlaku di seluruh situs.
Warna dan kontras
Tema
Gerakan
AnimasiSesuaikan perangkat mengikuti pengaturan pengurangan gerakan Anda.